Transforming Talk

Understanding therapy

Counselling or psychotherapy? Understanding the difference

The two words are often used to mean the same thing. Here’s where they overlap, where a distinction is made, and why it might matter when you’re choosing support.

Paul Reisbach4 November 20264 min read
An illustration of a tree with a root system below ground that is larger than the tree above it
Illustration: Transforming Talk

Two words, often used to mean the same thing

If you’ve started looking for support, you’ve probably come across both words, counselling and psychotherapy, often side by side. I use both myself, because that’s how most people search for help, and in everyday conversation the two are often used to mean the same thing.

There’s a great deal of overlap between them. Both offer a confidential relationship with a trained practitioner, both are built on being properly listened to, and in the room they can feel very similar. Practitioners don’t all draw the line in the same place, and some question whether it needs drawing at all.

Where a distinction is made, it tends to come down to focus, depth, length and training. Understanding these can help you think about what kind of support might fit you.

Where a distinction is made

Focus. Counselling tends to concentrate on a specific situation in the present, such as a bereavement, losing a job or a difficulty in a particular relationship. The work centres on that situation.

Depth. Psychotherapy can work with exactly the same situations. It also tends to look more broadly at the patterns underneath: past experiences, long-standing ways of relating to others and to ourselves, and how these shape what’s happening now. It can also work with what are often called mental health “disorders”. I use that word reluctantly, because I don’t like the idea of a person being disordered, but it’s the term in common use.

Length. Counselling is often shorter term and psychotherapy is often longer term, though psychotherapy can be short term too.

The back and the toe

An illustration may help. It’s a made-up example, and I’m not making any medical claim about backs.

Imagine someone goes to their doctor with back pain. The doctor examines their back, finds some swelling and prescribes anti-inflammatories. The pain carries on, and eventually they see a chiropractor, who asks them to stand up. Watching them stand, the chiropractor notices they’re favouring one leg slightly. Working down the other leg, they find some damage in one of the toes, perhaps a small fracture. That injury has been changing the way the person stands, and the strain has travelled all the way up to their back.

The back really did hurt, and it made sense to treat it. But the pain was also pointing to something else.

An example from practice

What brings someone to therapy is often the thing that hurts now. The example below is a composite drawn from different pieces of work, not a real client.

Someone comes to therapy because they’re struggling with grief. An old friend died several years ago. There’s no time limit on grief, but they feel they haven’t been able to settle back into life, and the loss keeps coming up.

Over a number of sessions, something else becomes clear. That friendship had carried them through some very difficult times in childhood. The friend had been a source of safety and security. Losing them brought up the fear that this support was gone, and with it, experiences from childhood that had never been fully processed.

So the shape of the work changed. It began with the bereavement, which is where counselling would typically focus. It moved towards the questions psychotherapy tends to ask: what did that friendship mean, and what from those earlier years still needed attention?

In my experience, this is common. People rarely come to therapy the first time something has happened. More often, there’s a pattern underneath what they’re experiencing.

Training routes

The training routes differ too. Counselling training starts at Level 4 and takes at least two years. Psychotherapy training starts at Level 7, which is master’s level, and typically takes four years.

These figures come from two of the main UK professional bodies, BACP and UKCP. Requirements vary between training organisations, and many practitioners train beyond the minimum.

In the UK, neither counselling nor psychotherapy is regulated by law, so it’s worth checking that any practitioner you’re considering is on a professional register, ideally one accredited by the Professional Standards Authority.

Choosing what fits you

Neither approach is better than the other. What matters is finding support that fits what you need now, and that can adapt if your needs change. It also matters for safety, yours and the practitioner’s, that the work stays within what the practitioner is trained to offer.

In my own practice, I offer psychotherapy using transactional analysis. If what you bring is very much of the moment, we can stay there. Often, though, there’s a pattern underneath, and that’s where we can go deeper, at a pace you set.

If you’re not sure what you need, that’s fine. Working it out is exactly what the free 30-minute chat is for.

References
BACP. Training to become a counsellor or psychotherapist. bacp.co.uk
UKCP. Train as a psychotherapist. psychotherapy.org.uk

Share this article

LinkedIn Facebook X Bluesky WhatsApp Email

Want to explore this with someone?

If something here feels familiar, we can look at it together. The first step is a free 30-minute chat by phone or video, with no obligation to continue.

Book a free chat

Further reading

Sessions and feesMore on my websiteStress is a warning lightStress Awareness Day · 4 min readI see you: why we all need strokesTA in everyday life · 4 min readAll articlesResources